Our extensive coverage of the truth behind TLC’s Breaking Amish reality series including all the cast members’ arrests, marriages, babies, and more!
Return To Amish star Sabrina Burkholder was released from jail on Monday after being behind bars for 10 days on multiple charges, including drug possession. It wasn’t long before the reality star was back on Facebook to thank those that sent her supportive messages, and to give an update on the custody situation with her…
We broke the news on Sunday that Return To Amish star Sabrina Burkholder is currently in jail after being arrested for multiple charges, including drug possession. Sabrina was scheduled for a hearing in Lancaster District Court Friday morning, and we have the results of that hearing. According to online records, Sabrina entered a guilty plea…
We have some very unfortunate news to report for fans of Return To Amish, as we can exclusively reveal that show star Sabrina Burkholder (aka Sabrina High) is currently in jail in Pennsylvania after being arrested for drug possession and other charges. Sabrina was officially booked May 11 on charges stemming from an incident on…
It’s been a little over two weeks since Return To Amish star Jeremiah Raber was arrested and charged with domestic violence after an altercation with his wife Carmela at their home in Florida. Carmela told police that Jeremiah “strikes her on a daily basis,” and the officer on the scene observed “several large bruises on…
America’s favorite band of former Amish reality stars returned to TLC Sunday night for the Return To Amish Season 5 premiere, but OG cast member Kate Stoltz was conspicuously absent. The (former?) reality star and current professional model and fashion design student took to Facebook to reply to the numerous fans wanting to know why…
Return To Amish star Jeremiah Raber was arrested in Florida last weekend and charged with domestic violence against his wife, Carmela Raber. According to the police report, Jeremiah allegedly threw hot coffee on Carmela’s lap after a verbal altercation, and she revealed to police officers that there was a frightening history of abuse that included…
As we reported earlier today, Return To Amish star Jeremiah Raber was arrested in Florida over the weekend on charges of domestic abuse against his wife, Carmela Raber. We have since obtained a copy of the affidavit from Jeremiah’s arrest, in which Carmela tells police some startling details about Jeremiah’s alleged abusive behavior. UPDATE –…
After marrying his wife Carmela and moving to Florida, it appeared that Return To Amish bad boy Jeremiah Raber had turned over a new leaf. But Jeremiah looks to be back to his old self, as he was arrested in Florida on Saturday and charged with domestic violence. UPDATE – Read the police report from…
We finally have a preview trailer and a premiere date for the new season of Return To Amish! We also have some rather shocking cast news as it is confirmed Kate Stoltz will not be returning to the show this season. First, here’s the preview trailer, which highlights some of the drama viewers can expect…
It looks like someone is going to get a lot of afghan making done as Breaking Amish: Return To Amish matriarch Moma Mary Schmucker is recovering after breaking her ankle in three places! Mary shared the news on Facebook along with a photo of her purple cast: I have not been on Facebook much lately…
Amid reports that the Breaking Amish OGs are filming a new season, the cast of Breaking Amish LA have gotten back together to film a reunion special! The news comes via cast member Lizzie James (formerly Lizzie Stoltzfus), who posted the photo above with her husband Hoj and cast mates Sam Stoltzfus and Matthew Bristol….
It has been just over a year since troubled Breaking Amish star Chapel Peace Schmucker found herself back behind bars after she and her sister were arrested for attempting to provide drug-free urine samples last January. Chapel was on probation at the time from a previous arrest in July of 2015 for heroin and Valium…
Breaking Amish: Return To Amish star Sabrina High had quite a bit to be thankful for this Thanksgiving as she welcomed her second daughter Arianna Grace at 6:57AM on Thanksgiving morning! Sabrina shared the news on Twitter earlier this month, along with the photos of Arianna above and below. In addition, Sabrina revealed that Oakely’s…
Breaking Amish: Return To Amish bad boy Jeremiah Raber shocked cast mates and fans this past season when he married 34-year-old Carmela from Vancouver, Washington after the two met via Facebook. Despite a few bumps in the road, Jermela is still going strong and recently announced they have bought a home in Florida! Jeremiah first…
In the two-hour season finale of Return To Amish, Jeremiah Raber’s co-stars (sans Kate Stoltz) made the trip out to Vancouver, Washington to finally meet Jeremiah’s fiance Carmela Mendez before attending the couple’s wedding. Prior to the ceremony, Carmela explained her past to Sabrina, Rebecca, and Esther, and revealed that she was raised in a…
Just when it looked as though Return To Amish star Sabrina High was getting her life on track, a recent tragic incident may have thrown her back into chaos. Although details are still sketchy, it appears that Children and Youth Services have once again taken Sabrina’s daughter Oakley from her — but not because of…
Tonight is the dramatic two-hour season finale of Breaking Amish: Return To Amish in which show bad boy Jeremiah Raber walks down the aisle with his fiancee Carmela Mendez. Aside from one “tweet and delete” picture on Facebook, Jeremiah and Carmela (and TLC) have kept all of their weddings photos locked up in a virtual…
Return To Amish star Jeremiah Raber’s dream to make the leap from the small screen to the big screen may still be alive as it was just announced the scandal-ridden production of the Amish-themed horror film The Plain People is once again a go, with Jeremiah as the star. The announcement came via the film’s…
Return To Amish co-stars Jeremiah Raber and Kate Stoltz have always seemed to have a tenuous friendship at best, but now it appears to be over for good after Jeremiah declared his hatred of Kate on Twitter before calling her a liar and a fake — apparently due in large part to Kate not attending…
I don’t think there is a reality star out there who shares more brutally honest and humble reactions to episodes than Return To Amish star Sabrina High. A recovering drug addict, Sabrina has held nothing back in her numerous Facebook posts about her road to recovery and her successful attempt to regain custody of her…
Return To Amish bad boy Jeremiah Raber and wife Carmela got married back in April, but the life of a reality star bride is not proving to be all sunshine and lollipops for this mother of four from Vancouver, Washington. Carmela found herself at the center of a controversy after production on a film set…
Return To Amish star Kate Stoltz is normally rather subdued and positive on her social media accounts, but the new season of the show has really set her off as she continues to angrily lash out at show producers claiming that cast members were “bullied and harassed while filming” and that “producers even released articles…
TLC’s popular reality series Return To Amish (formerly Breaking Amish) returns this Sunday, and at least one cast member is not thrilled about it. Model and fashion designer Kate Stoltz took to Twitter yesterday to express her frustration at ever having agreed to appear on the show, apparently due to the creative liberties taken by…
Return To Amish comes back Sunday night, and TLC has released some additional preview clips revealing some of the dramatic moments in store for fans this season! Because it was set to autoplay, we will start with Entertainment Tonight‘s clip featuring a scene from the premiere episode in which Mama Mary reveals she wants to…
We’re only one week away from the brand new season of Return To Amish, and as we previously revealed, show OG Sabrina High will be returning as a full-time cast member after missing a season due to her issues with drug addiction. Sabrina, who is currently pregnant with her second child, has been extremely honest…
It was announced late last year that Breaking Amish star Jeremiah Raber would be making the transition from the small screen to the big screen as an actor in the Amish-themed horror film The Plain People. But, after more than eight months’ preparation, the filmmakers have announced the project has been canceled because they were forced to release…
We’ve been updating Breaking Amish fans on the life of original cast member Sabrina High for a while now as she has struggled to overcome numerous obstacles in her life, including drug addiction and being in an abusive relationship. Thankfully, she has gotten her life back on track with months of sobriety under her belt…
Breaking Amish fans rejoice! TLC has just released the first preview trailer for the new season of Return To Amish as the cast pays tribute to their debut by returning to the Big Apple on July 10. Judging from the preview trailer, here are some things we can expect to see this season: The Schmucker…
We have some really great news to report for fans of Breaking Amish and Return To Amish as show star Sabrina High has just regained custody of her two-year-old daughter Oakley after months of sobriety. “I was granted full physical custody of Oakley this morning by the courts and the state,” Sabrina proudly declared on…
UPDATE – Carmela has since removed the wedding photo she posted, and at the request of Jeremiah, we have removed it from the post. If they reconsider and decide to share photos publicly again, we will update the post. We have kept the snaps of Jeremiah and his Return To Amish co-stars (and Carmela!) chillin’…
I realize that when a show goes an entire year between seasons a lot can happen, but I never would have guessed a year would be long enough for this to happen! Breaking Amish: Return To Amish bad boy Jeremiah Raber is getting married! Like next week! The news won’t come as a huge shock…
Breaking Amish and Return to Amish sisters Katie Ann and Esther Schmucker were involved in a serious car accident earlier today. Sources close to the family first broke the news on Facebook, revealing that both Esther and Katie Ann were life flighted to a hospital after the accident. The siblings’ sister-in-law, show star Rebecca Schmucker,…
Troubled Breaking Amish: Return To Amish star Chapel Peace Schmucker is back in jail after allegedly attempting to provide drug-free urine samples. Also caught yellow-handed was Chapel’s sister, Ashley Vega. From Explore Jefferson: On January 4, the Borough of Punxsutawney Police Department received a call to report to 222 N. Findley Street, the Adult Probation…
As we previously reported, the OGs of TLC’s Breaking Amish are returning for another season of Return To Amish–and, according to a new bombshell report, it could be the most scandalous season yet! Enstars just shared a series of videos that allegedly show Abe Schmucker’s best friend Mike Spencer leaving Rebecca and Abe’s house in the early morning…
Return To Amish matriarch Mama Mary Schmucker said back in May that the previous season of the show would be her last, but it appears that she and the rest of the Breaking Amish OGs have had a change of heart as Rebecca Schmucker has confirmed they have begun filming again with a premiere set…
Normally, a $100 iTunes gift card is a pretty safe gift for just about anyone–but for Breaking Amish matriarch Mama Mary Schmucker, not so much. Mary revealed earlier today that she received the generous gift from TLC for her birthday, but revealed “I have no use for it” before then offering it for sale for $80. Here’s…
We have some more good news to share from former Breaking Amish and Return To Amish star Sabrina High! As we reported last month, Sabrina is currently sober and seems to really be getting her life back together after moving back in with her parents. However, there was still one major piece missing: her 17-month-old…
Return To Amish star Chapel Peace was sentenced earlier today for her July arrest for possession of heroin and Valium. The 33-year-old reality star and mother of two was given two years probation and ordered to complete 28 days in a drug rehabilitation facility. The outcome seems to be positive for Chapel, who will avoid further…
When the original cast of Breaking Amish came back for another season of Return To Amish, many were disappointed that fan-favorite Sabrina High was no longer on the show. Sabrina explained with a rather vague Facebook post back in May why she did not return–the post referenced the traumatizing events in her life that led…
Return To Amish star Chapel Peace has had a very difficult year. In addition to dealing with (or at least claiming to deal with — more on that below) the return of her cancer in the fall, the arrest of her husband Andrew Schmucker, and a very serious car crash involving her sister Ashley, Chapel…
Breaking Amish and Return to Amish star Chapel Peace was arrested Saturday and charged with multiple counts of drug and drug paraphernalia possession. The arrest comes after months of reports from friends and family that she was struggling with drug addiction, and several disturbingly dark Facebook posts made by Chapel herself. According to the police…
Back in April, Breaking Amish: LA star Elizabeth ‘Betsy’ Yoder and husband Allen Yoder announced they were expecting their first child together. Betsy’s due date wasn’t until October, but, last week, she was hospitalized with a UTI–and, while receiving antibiotics via IV, she began to experience contractions and heavy bleeding. The complications led to last night’s…
On this season of Return To Amish, fans have seen Mama Mary Schmucker and her crew attempt to renovate an old house–which turns out to be haunted–and convert it into an Amish bed and breakfast. Who could have guessed that way back in Season 1? So: what is the fate of the Mama Maryott hotel? Mary…
The bad luck continues for Return To Amish star Chapel Schmucker and her family. Chapel’s sister Ashley Vega (seen on the right with Chapel on the left in the photo above) was airlifted to a Pittsburgh hospital after being involved in a serious car accident. Chapel first shared the news with fans on Facebook on May 21,…
Over the last few years, fans of TLC’s Breaking Amish have been able to follow the amazing journey of star Katie Stoltzfus, who left the Amish community in hopes of pursuing a professional modeling career — and then MADE IT HAPPEN! Obviously, Katie (who now goes by Kate Stoltz) has needed to make a lot of adjustments over…
When Breaking Amish: Return To Amish returns to TLC tonight, one member of the original cast will be missing: former Mennonite Sabrina High. Her absence from the preview clips and the promotional material for the new season had many people asking if she was going to be on the show at all, and, if not, why? Sabrina, her…
Breaking Amish reality star and self-proclaimed “Amish Rebel” Jeremiah Raber is back behind bars again. The 35-year-old was arrested in Pennsylvania early Saturday morning after allegedly yelling obscenities at state troopers while being driven home from a bar. According to Pennsylvania troopers, the vehicle in which Jeremiah was a passenger was pulled over in White…
Breaking Amish bad boy Jeremiah Raber will be returning to TLC along with all of the other original cast members (except Sabrina) for a fourth, and reportedly last, season on May 31. The 35-year-old father of three recently sat down with Blastzone Online and talked about how he originally got on the show, what fans…
The Breaking Amish OGs return to TLC on May 31 for their fourth (and reportedly last) season, and earlier this week the network released the first preview trailer that indicates fans are in for lots of drama, including more arrests, medical emergencies, and Jeremiah being a dad! Here’s the clip: Here’s what we know: The…
It’s the end of an era as Breaking Amish matriarch Mama Mary Schmucker announced today that the upcoming season of TLC’s Breaking Amish: Return to Amish will be her last. In a “little update” posted to Facebook earlier today, Mary shared “what people don’t know about shunning” and revealed that being shunned has been a…
Breaking Amish couple Rebecca and Abe Schmucker are seemingly living out a rare reality show happily ever after! The two are now happily married with a house and two lovely daughters: Kayla (age 4) and Malika (now a year and four months). But, after being asked by numerous fans if she and Abe were planning…
The original inspirations for the term “Dramish” are returning as TLC announced this week that the OGs of Breaking Amish are coming back for another season of Return to Amish at 9/8c on Thursday, May 31! Here is the scoop on what fans can expect from the network’s press release: In the season premiere of…
Breaking Amish matriarch Mama Mary Schmucker is currently recovering after having surgery earlier this week. She was previously hospitalized in January for issues stemming from a hernia, but she was later released and seemed to be doing well enough to require no further medical attention. But the Facebook page for her son Abe and daughter-in-law…
We have some exciting news for fans of TLC’s Breaking Amish LA as show star Elizabeth “Betsy” Yoder announced moments ago on Facebook that she is pregnant with her and husband Allen Yoder’s first child! Betsy made the announcement with the side-by-side photos above featuring herself and Allen as well as a sonogram with the…
Fans are deeply concerned today after Breaking Amish stars Rebecca and Abe Schmucker posted a call for prayers for show matriarch Mama Mary Schmucker on Facebook. “We are asking for Prayers for this awesome mom!!!” reads the initial Facebook statement, which included the photo of Mary riding in a limo below. “Please pray that she…
Fans of meat in a jar rejoice! Breaking Amish matriarch Mama Mary Schmucker has published her own cookbook, now available for just $10 plus $5 shipping and handling! Keep reading for all the details, inclduing how to order yours today!
Everyone’s favorite Amish reality show mom is a grandmother yet again! Breaking Amish‘s Mary Schmucker (mother of Andrew and Abe Schmucker) shared a photo holding her newest grandson on Facebook over the weekend and wrote, “My new Grandson John Wayne Schmucker is 6 pounds 13 ounces 19 inches long.” Keep reading for more info and another picture of lil John Wayne.
TLC cameras were rolling for Breaking Amish Season 4 as troubled star Andrew Schmucker appeared in a Jefferson County Courthouse recently after a probation violation landed him back in jail. Keep reading to find out how much more time Andrew will be spending behind bars and in rehab for his latest offense as well as an update on his wife, Chapel Peace Schmucker.
Apparently we aren’t the only ones who admire what Breaking Amish star Kate Stoltzfus has managed accomplish since first appearing on the original installment of TLC’s Breaking Amish! The 24-year-old, who goes by Kate Stoltz professionally, was honored at the 2014 Demiurge Awards Tuesday night for her work on television, professional modeling and fashion design. Keep reading to see photos from the event, including models wearing Kate’s designs, as well as photos of Kate rocking some rather avant-garde lingerie for a Love Cage NYC fashion show!
In Breaking Amish LA ‘Where Are They Now?’ news, cast member Lizzie Ann Stoltzfus married her fiance, and father of her son Kaden, Hoj James in a beautiful ceremony last week. Keep reading to see wedding photos including Kaden as well as lots of pictures from the couple’s amazing engagement photo shoot!
| Cookie | Duration | Description |
|---|---|---|
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional | 11 months | The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-others | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. |
| cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance | 11 months | This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". |
| viewed_cookie_policy | 11 months | The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data. |