The most recent season of Return To Amish wrapped up earlier this month, but the drama continues off screen for show star Jeremiah Raber. In a recent Facebook post, his ex-wife Naomi Stutzman posted a purported screen cap from her account on the Ohio website for tracking child support that indicates Jeremiah was a wee bit behind — as in $10,000+ behind!
The last time we checked in with Return To Amish star Sabrina Burkholder was in August when she shared news that she was headed to a rehabilitation facility “for a long time” in hopes of finally getting her drug addiction issues under control. What Sabrina didn’t reveal was that she was pregnant at the time!
On Sunday night’s episode of Return To Amish, Shelly finally worked up the nerve to call her birth mother, who she had not seen since she was four years old. The conversation took a very unexpected turn when her mother made some very startling claims about Shelly’s adopted parents!
RETURN TO AMISH Jeremiah says $15k that Carmela ‘stole’ was her own money, both react to negative comments
Return to Amish stars Jeremiah Raber and wife Carmela Raber took to YouTube to share their responses to the Season 5 Premiere as well as comments made about them on social media after it aired. Jeremiah makes sure to clarify that the $15,000 in cash that Carmela took was actually hers, and he also addresses his “no ‘i’ in marriage” comment — among many other things. Check out the videos and get a full recap of their responses!
RETURN TO AMISH Jeremiah’s Amish Donuts business, new cast intros, Sabrina spits on Jeremiah, more in new preview
TLC’s Return To Amish comes back this Sunday with some of the original cast members and at least three new cast members. Judging from a new sneak peek video, it appears as though the new season will hinge around Jeremiah Raber and the Amish Donuts business he has been associated with since 2016, with the three new cast members being potential new hires looking to go English!
When Return To Amish Season 5 premieres on November 18 fans will be seeing some familiar faces in “Mama Mary” Schmucker, Sabrina Burkholder, Jeremiah Raber, and Carmela Raber — but who are all these new faces?
Breaking Amish: Return To Amish star Rebecca Schmucker responds to our tweet about the new season by confirming that she and husband Abe Schmucker (and their two daughters) will not be back when the show returns November 18. Keep reading for her full statement explaining their decision to leave reality television behind.
We’ve known for at least six months that the cast members of Return to Amish were filming for a new season, and TLC surprised fans during Sunday night’s Before the 90 Days Couples Tell All special by releasing the very first preview trailer that included the premiere date — as well as three new cast members who are just now leaving the Amish church!?