It’s been three-and-a-half years since WE tv’s prison romance reality series Love After Lockup made its debut in January of 2018. During that time, the show has featured 29 ex-convicts hoping to find love after lockup. That number increases if you include non-official cast members like Lacey’s boo John and Amber’s bunkie Puppy.

With roughly 30 former inmates, it becomes very difficult for fans to keep up with which cast members managed to stay out of jail, which ones were arrested again, and which ones are currently back behind bars. I’ve written every one of the 268 Love After Lockup articles published on Starcasm over the years, and I confess that even I have difficulty keeping up!

So, I have decided to put together a series of posts documenting the recidivism for all of the inmates featured on the show. The posts will include easy-to-read graphics as well as information about the inmates’ arrests after appearing on the show — complete with links.

Due to the sheer number of inmates and arrests, I will need to split the posts up into seasons. Unfortunately, WE tv has elected to break the series down into seasons that don’t make any sense whatsoever, so I will use a more logical system that is more in line with cast turnover.

This first post will combine the first two seasons of the show because there were only 10 total inmates featured. (That number increases to 11 if we include Clint Brady, as I have done below.)

UPDATE – Over time, this post grew a bit lengthy due to the many arrests of the inmates. As a result, we have added a separate article with the Love After Lockup Season 2 inmate chart.

Here are the links to our recidivism charts for the other seasons. I think fans will clearly see that our method of breaking down the seasons makes much more sense:

Love After Lockup Season 3 updates for inmates Shane, Amber, Josh, Daniel, Lamondre and Alex. Post includes arrest updates for John, Vincent and Puppy.

Love After Lockup Season 4 updates for inmates Lindsey, Dylan, Destinie, Maurice, Chanda, Quaylon and Kristianna.

Love After Lockup Season 5 updates for inmates Nicolle, Josh, Ray, Jeff, Lisa, Doug and Tia.

Which Love After Lockup inmates have been arrested again?

Season One

wp-image-450321″ />

Garrett Tanner

Garrett turned out to be a pretty terrible fiancé for Johnna DiGrigoli. (Does anyone else remember all the “Natural” Nelly girlfriend drama?)

If I had been forced to bet on whether or not Garrett would stay out of jail and/or prison, I definitely would have bet against him. However, aside from a careless driving incident and Nelly’s marijuana possession arrest (with a mystery man that was probably Garrett in the vehicle with her), Garrett has had no run-ins with the law that I am aware of.

Garrett has since relocated to New York, and he briefly made some extra coin with an Only Fans account. Here’s an update post from Garrett on Instagram made in March of 2020:

Been home from prison for 3 years today!! I’m Blessed!! I was in prison from 2010-2017 came home March 24th!!! Even though me Nelly don’t speak she played a big roll in helping me stay grounded and keeping me out of the streets. My Family has been here for me through it all!! I have some good friends and I appreciate al my followers too!!! God is good!! 🙏🏼💯 #blessed #free #nomorechaingang And my PRR is up today!! No enhancements!!! No mandatory sentence!! 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

September 13, 2020 – Garrett Tanner arrested for DUI in Florida. According to the arrest report, Garrett was pulled over after driving at night with his headlights off. From the arrest report:

Upon making contact with the defendant, he displayed multiple indicators of impairment, including: slow response to signal to pull over, bloodshot/glassy eyes, a strong odor of an alcoholic beverage on his breath, fumbling fingers while searching for his documents, and lethargic reflexes. The defendant performed poorly on the SFSEs was arrested for DUI.

The defendant was also found in possession of a bottle of tequila, which was half full of a clear liquid which had a the odor and appearance of tequila. The defendant later refused to submit to the breath test, despite being advised of the Implied Consent Warning.

October 5, 2021 – Garrett pleads no contest to a reduced charge of reckless driving. As part of the plea deal, Garrett is sentenced to one year of probation, 50 hours of community service, DUI school, and a $500 fine.

October 3, 2022 – Garrett is arrested for failure to appear for a September, 2022 court hearing. The hearing was in regards to Garrett not complying with his probation requirements.

February 7, 2023 – Garrett is arrested for failure to appear for a January, 2023 hearing. Garrett’s probation was terminated as unsuccessful on February 24, 2023.

Lizzie Kommes

Lizzie seemed to be well on her way to a happily ever after with a full-time factory job and claims of being completely sober. However, a recent tumultuous relationship resulted in multiple arrests and Lizzie’s admission that she has not been sober at all. She’s recently returned to posting bikini photos (with ankle monitor) and snapshots of her daily devotional on Instagram. Only time will tell if Lizzie has truly left her troubled times behind this time.

Lizzie arrest 1, Lizzie arrest 2, Lizzie arrest 3

Tony Wood

As documented on screen, Tony’s love of prostitutes and freedom inspired him to miss his halfway house curfew in April of 2018. Tony went on the lam and used his cunning and guile to elude police for three whole days. To Tony’s credit, he managed to travel nearly 2,000 miles before being apprehended in Reno, Nevada.

Amazingly, Tony’s arrest in Reno was his last to date. However, his love of prostitutes and freedom have inspired him to travel once again. According to Angela, Tony took their car plus $4,000 of her money and ran off to Idaho where his mother lives. Will he be able to stay out of legal trouble? Stay tuned.

Lamar Jackson

Lamar served the longest time in prison of any of the Love After Lockup inmates — by far. 18 years for armed robbery! As perhaps the best example from the show of folks deserving a second chance, Lamar has seemingly been living well. Personally, I give a huge amount of credit to Andrea’s AMAZING kids!

UPDATE – According to Andrea (and WE tv producers) Lamar was arrested on a parole violation and served at least five months before being released again.

Dominic Dalla Nora

Canadian Dom was involved in a brutal bar fight in 2009 that resulted in a six-year sentence for aggravated assault. To be honest, I don’t feel like we got to know Dom very well on the show, mostly due to him being kind of reserved (aside from some of his disagreements with Mary). Since his prison release featured on the show, Dom has had no legal troubles that I am aware of.

Given that we didn’t get to know Dom that well, I honestly had no opinion on his chances of remaining out of jail and/or prison. However, given what we saw of his relationship with Mary, I was anything but optimistic about their chances of staying together. Boy was I wrong! The couple are still married, and Mary announced just last month that she is currently pregnant with their second child. Dom and Mary have definitely been one of the show’s happiest ever afters!

Alla Subbotina

As viewers of Love After Lockup Season 1 know, Alla returned to prison not long after her release due to her drug addiction issues. She was released from prison again on Christmas Eve of 2019, but she was back behind bars just four weeks later. After serving roughly a year and a half, Alla was released again in early July of this year.

Alla’s parents revealed in August of 2021 that Alla passed away from an apparent drug overdose on August 7. She was just 31 years old.

Asa Hawks is a writer and editor for Starcasm. You can contact Asa via Twitter, Facebook, or email at starcasmtips(at)yahoo.com