90 DAY FIANCÉ Shea’s daughter Madison’s assault mug shot was the talk of the town on Facebook
Shea McGuire and Nicole Hayden’s daughter Madison made her 90 Day Fiancé debut on this week’s episode, but the 20-year-old is no stranger to public attention.
Following in her mother’s footsteps, Madison is already amassing a collection of mug shot photos — one of which got quite a bit of attention on a local arrests Facebook page.
The mug shot (above) was from a 2025 arrest for assault causing minor injury, intimidating a participant in the legal process, and retaliating against a participant in the legal process. In the photo, which looks to have been taken in the back seat of a police car, Madison is wearing a white t-shirt with a pony tail and some rather remarkable eyelash extensions.
Below is a sampling of some of the comments on the post:
Madison’s mom Nicole, sister Allison, and even Madison herself got in on the comment fun, with a little bit of defending as well from mom:
COMMENT: The lashes eattttttt 😍
REPLY: yess! I wanna know who did them lol
NICOLE: I got yaw in a couple hours when I get her out of there.
* * * * *
ALLISON: Face card never declines 🥵
NICOLE: On any day! 🫶🏻
* * * * *
NICOLE: On my way to scoop her now for all her friends asking. Lash lady info on the way 😑😂
MADISON: IM FREE YALL! & never going back 🫰🏼🫰🏼 not for me 🥰
* * * * *
COMMENT: She’s so young and beautiful sometimes people deserve second chances dont know always the whole story.. and if she is struggling on anything get her help.
NICOLE: There’s a lot of false reporting going on and trust me, she’s got a team of people behind her. She’s not perfect but she’s a great person and a beautiful mother inside and out.
#90DayFiance Shea McGuire described his ex-wife Nicole as "trouble" on the show, and it appears multiple police departments in Kentucky might agree.
Check out Nicole's mugshots with a timeline of her arrests: https://t.co/OU20U2LlCl pic.twitter.com/5iScE1D0o1
— Starcasm (@starcasm) May 18, 2026
COMMENT: The same charges as the other young girl! How is that gentle parenting thing going?
NICOLE: Never been a gentle parent. Haha. This is my girl and she probably got more ssa whoopings than your grannies granny, growing up. 😂
REPLY: I hope she got another one when she got out. I got one kid that is like this and I definitely didn’t gentle parent. Stay strong mama.
* * * * *
COMMENT: Y’all, it’s a bunch of em. 🤣 scroll down and look at these poor, misguided youth.
NICOLE: That’s my daughter, friend. And she’s not misguided. I have taught her right from wrong. And she knows what the deal is. Speaking on things you don’t know about is silly. We are old. Let’s stop doing this!
REPLY: This was a sarcastic comment. I thought that was obvious.
NICOLE: I didn’t take it as that. My bad.
Madison has at least two other mug shot photos from 2025, one of which was from a different county on the same day as her “T-E-A” pic (on the left below). The third mug shot was months later.
Jail records indicate similar charges for all three bookings, so I assume they stem from the same incident. Starcasm has not been able to obtain any information on the charges or the incident(s) that resulted in Madison’s arrest(s).
Asa Hawks is a writer and editor for Starcasm. You can contact Asa via Twitter, Facebook, or email at starcasmtips(at)yahoo.com
