Everyone’s first time is memorable. But, Gregg Casarona’s was undeniably more memorable than most others: In an upcoming episode of TLC’s Sex Sent Me to the ER, Gregg recalled how his first time hooking up with girlfriend Jen Gerakaris resulted in a trip to the hospital.*
The painful experience began when 110-lb. Jen decided to put the moves on her virgin boyfriend of a month.
“We were dating for a little while and he hadn’t put any moves on me yet so I made a move,” Jen told The Post.
Gregg didn’t require much convincing. Before long, they were hot and heavy — particularly Gregg, who was four times larger than his girlfriend. With so much cushion doin’ the pushing, Gregg accidentally propelled Jen into the sheet-rock wall.
“My initial reaction was, ‘I killed her… This is my first time. And Jen is dead,'” Gregg said.
Thankfully, Jen had a real sense of humor about it all.
“He looked like he was about to have a heart attack. So I just wanted to lighten the mood,” she said, explaining she asked him why he stopped.
Even though Jen tried to laugh it off, Gregg insisted they go to the hospital. Jen was then diagnosed with a concussion.
After that incident, the couple learned how to deal with their weight discrepancies.
“In the beginning, there were lots of pillows and we didn’t do it anywhere near a wall,” Jen said, explaining they worked out the kinks throughout their four-year relationship. They’ve since split, but remain friends. “It’s a story we always tell over drinks.”
*Reenactment photo courtesy of TLC.
