| |

LOVE DURING LOCKUP Justin Johnson’s grandma sues prison; he was 8th suicide in 4 years

Starcasm shares exclusive details about the lawsuit filed by late Love During Lockup star Justin Johnson's grandmother

As Starcasm was the first to report, Love During Lockup star Justin Johnson passed away on July 12, 2025 while incarcerated at SCI Houtzdale state prison in Pennsylvania. He was just 35 years old.

At the time of our initial report, Justin’s official cause of death had not been released. It was later determined he took his own life by hanging after fashioning a ligature from braided T-shirts

Justin is one of eight inmates to take their own lives at SCI Houtzdale since David Close was appointed Acting Superintendent of the prison in 2022. There have been multiple lawsuits filed against the prison and Superintendent Close relating to the suicides, including one lawsuit on behalf of Justin Johnson’s estate.

JUSTIN JOHNSON’S GRANDMOTHER SUES PRISON WHERE HE DIED

TMZ first reported that Justin Johnson’s grandmother, Paulette J. Spackman, filed a lawsuit against Superintendent Close and multiple correctional officers at SCI Houtzdale “alleging the guards there didn’t monitor him closely enough.”

TMZ’s brief recap of the lawsuit reveals that “Spackman says the officers are required to visually confirm the condition of each inmate at regular intervals … but, on the night of Justin’s suicide, she claims officers left him alone for 90 minutes with a covering over his window.”

Justin wasn’t discovered by a corrections officer, but by his cellmate. “She says his body was already cold to the touch.”

The lawsuit states Justin had a documented history of mental health and substance abuse issues prior to his death. “She’s suing the officials for supervisory liability/failure to train and supervise, deliberate indifference, and wrongful death.”

JUSTIN JOHNSON LAWSUIT EXCLUSIVE DETAILS

Starcasm has obtained a copy of the lawsuit filed on behalf of Justin Johnson’s estate and we can share additional details from the filing.

The lawsuit, originally filed on November 11, is thorough and the information is presented clearly without a lot of legalese. For that reason, Starcasm has chosen to simply share lengthy excerpts from the complaint.

INTRODUCTION

This civil rights action arises from the preventable suicide of Justin Jack Johnson while incarcerated at SCI Houtzdale on July 12, 2025. Justin did not take his life during a brief interval between otherwise adequate security rounds. For more than 90 minutes, Justin remained alone inside his cell with his window completely covered while the correctional officers responsible for his safety repeatedly passed his cell and purported to conduct required security and welfare rounds without ever obtaining a direct visual observation of him.

SCI Houtzdale’s post orders required the correctional officers to make a direct visual observation into each cell during security rounds and to visibly confirm each inmate, including checking for signs of distress, abnormal behavior, or concerning physical condition. The correctional officers were also trained that inmates were prohibited from covering their cell windows because doing so prevented meaningful observation and presented an obvious and immediate safety and suicide risk. Yet, the correctional officers completed at least 4 rounds while Justin’s window remained obstructed, took no action to remove the obstruction or determine his condition, and nevertheless marked those rounds complete as though they had visually confirmed that Justin was alive and safe.

These failures did not occur in isolation. Before Justin’s death, Superintendent David Close was already aware of repeated suicides, suicide attempts, and serious deficiencies in suicide prevention and inmate monitoring at SCI Houtzdale. Those prior incidents placed Close on notice that correctional officers were failing to adequately monitor inmates at risk of self-harm, that required security and welfare observations were not being meaningfully performed, and that inadequate training, supervision, enforcement, and corrective action created an obvious risk that another inmate would die by suicide. Despite that notice, Close failed to take reasonable measures to correct those known deficiencies, ensure meaningful compliance with required observation procedures, or adequately train and supervise correctional staff regarding suicide prevention and obstructed cell windows.

Against that backdrop, Justin’s mental health deteriorated in the days immediately preceding his death. He had a documented depressive disorder, appeared increasingly sad and withdrawn, and, on the evening of July 12, declined recreation and remained alone inside his cell. While the correctional officers continued to ignore his covered window, Justin fashioned a ligature from braided T- shirts, attached it to the overhead light fixture or grate, and hanged himself. No correctional officer discovered him. At approximately 7:36 p.m., Justin’s returning cellmate entered the cell and found him slumped and hanging. By then, Justin was already cold to the touch.

When medical personnel arrived, Justin was pulseless, apneic, unresponsive, and visibly cyanotic. He never regained a pulse. The subsequent investigation documented lividity and rigor mortis, and the autopsy revealed a 55 centimeter long ligature furrow that nearly completely encircled his neck. Justin’s death was not the product of an unforeseeable act that correctional staff had no meaningful opportunity to detect. It was the foreseeable result of correctional officers repeatedly failing to perform meaningful observations of an inmate concealed behind an obstructed window and a supervisory system that, despite repeated warning signs and prior suicides, failed to ensure that those basic suicide prevention measures were actually followed.

FACTS

…Prior to his death, Justin had a documented history of mental illness and substance use disorder known to the PADOC.

Justin’s PADOC medical records identified unspecified depressive disorder as a chronic condition and further documented a history of opioid abuse.

In the days immediately preceding his death, Justin’s mental and emotional condition significantly deteriorated.

Justin’s cellmate observed that Justin appeared increasingly sad and withdrawn.

Justin also visited with his grandparents on July 11, 2025. After that visit, Justin appeared visibly upset according to his cellmate.

By July 12, 2025, Justin’s psychological deterioration had become increasingly pronounced.

At approximately 6:00 p.m. on July 12, 2025, Justin’s cellmate left their cell to participate in the housing unit’s optional recreational period.

Justin declined to participate and instead remained alone inside the cell.

Thereafter, Justin covered the cell window, obstructing the ability of the CO Defendants to visually observe him from outside the cell.

…SCI Houtzdale’s post orders for Justin’s housing unit required the CO Defendants to “make direct visual observation into each cell during a security round” and that “each inmate should be visibly confirmed including checking for signs of distress, abnormal behavior, or physical condition.”

SCI Houtzdale’s policies and procedures and training strictly prohibit inmates from obstructing their cell windows as it is a well-known indicator of an immediate suicide risk and would prevent them from conducting a proper security and/or wellness round.

However, upon information and belief, one or more of the CO Defendants completed at least 4 security/wellness rounds while Justin’s cell window was obstructed without addressing it, ensuring he was safe, or otherwise confirming that he was alive despite understanding the immediate suicide risk that the covering posed.

A covered window necessarily prevented any of the CO Defendants conducting a meaningful visual observation from determining Justin’s condition or even confirming that he was alive and responsive.

One or more of the CO Defendants nonetheless marked their rounds as complete representing that they visually confirmed that Justin was alive and well.

Further, upon information and belief, during this period one or more of the CO Defendants passed Justin’s cell on multiple other occasions while the cell window remained covered, yet failed to remove the obstruction, obtain a direct visual observation of Justin, assess his condition, or otherwise intervene despite the obvious safety and suicide risks presented by an inmate remaining isolated behind a covered cell window.

Nevertheless, Justin remained alone behind the covered window for over 90 minutes without any CO Defendant discovering or responding to the obstruction.

Surveillance footage reviewed by the Pennsylvania State Police confirms that, as late as approximately 7:36 p.m., Justin’s window remained covered.

If the required security/wellness rounds were conducted properly during this period, one or more of the CO Defendants encountered, or should have encountered, the covered window and nevertheless failed to take action to obtain an unobstructed view of Justin and verify his safety.

At approximately 7:36 p.m., Justin’s cellmate returned to the cell and immediately observed that the cell window was covered.

Justin’s cellmate remained outside the cell for a few minutes before ultimately entering.

However, when Justin’s cellmate entered the cell, he discovered Justin slumped and hanging from the overhead light fixture or grate by a ligature fashioned from braided T-shirts.

It was Justin’s fellow inmate, rather than the CO Defendants who were tasked with ensuring Justin’s safety, who discovered him.

LOVE DURING LOCKUP Justin’s friend trashes Emily after his passing

By the time the cellmate discovered Justin, Justin was already cold to the touch which was consistent with Justin having been hanging for a substantial period before any CO Defendant became aware of his condition.
Justin’s cellmate attempted to free Justin and yelled for assistance.

Only after inmates alerted the CO Defendants to the emergency did they finally respond to Justin’s cell.

Upon entering the cell, the CO Defendants found Justin unresponsive, cut him down, and began cardiopulmonary resuscitation.

Medical personnel arrived at approximately 7:41 p.m. and found Justin pulseless, apneic, unresponsive, and visibly cyanotic around his mouth, face, and fingertips.

The presence of visible cyanosis around Justin’s mouth, face, and fingertips, together with his pulseless, apneic, and unresponsive condition, was consistent with Justin having experienced a significant period of oxygen deprivation before medical personnel arrived and indicated that his medical emergency had begun before he was discovered.

Justin never regained a pulse.

The automated external defibrillator repeatedly analyzed Justin’s cardiac rhythm but never advised that a shock be administered.

Justin was pronounced dead at approximately 8:04 p.m. on July 12, 2025. His cause of death was determined to be asphyxiation by hanging, and his death was ruled a suicide.

…Justin’s death was preventable and occurred as a direct and foreseeable consequence of Defendants’ deliberate indifference to his safety.

SCI HOUTZDALE’S HISTORY OF SUICIDES

The constitutional violations described herein were not isolated acts, but instead occurred as a result of a pattern and practice of deliberate indifference to inmate safety and suicide risk at SCI Houtzdale, which was known to, tolerated by, and acquiesced in by Superintendent Close.

In or around early 2022, Superintendent Close was appointed Acting Superintendent of SCI Houtzdale, having previously served as the institution’s Deputy Superintendent.

Prior to Superintendent Close’s appointment, SCI Houtzdale had experienced just 2 reported inmate suicides dating back to 2019, according to statistics maintained pursuant to Pennsylvania’s Death in Custody Reporting Act: Gerald Bowman on September 30, 2019, and Joel Snider on March 31, 2021.

However, following Superintendent Close’s assumption of leadership, SCI Houtzdale experienced a dramatic and alarming escalation in inmate suicides, transforming what had previously been relatively isolated incidents into a persistent and foreseeable pattern of preventable deaths. Indeed, under Superintendent Close’s supervision and control, inmate suicides at SCI Houtzdale reached what can only be characterized as epidemic proportions, evidencing a systemic and institutional failure to protect inmates at known risk of suicide.

To date, since Superintendent Close’s appointment, at least 7 other incarcerated persons at SCI Houtzdale also died by suicide, demonstrating a recurring and systemic failure to adequately identify inmates at risk of self-harm, properly train and supervise correctional and medical staff in suicide prevention, conduct required observations and welfare checks, recognize and respond to warning signs of suicidal behavior, communicate critical mental health information among staff, and timely intervene during psychiatric and medical emergencies.

The frequency of these suicides further placed Superintendent Close on notice of deficiencies in SCI Houtzdale’s suicide prevention practices, including its policies, training, monitoring, supervision, and procedures for identifying and protecting vulnerable inmates, yet those deficiencies were permitted to continue through the time of Justin’s death.

These suicide deaths include:

Matthew Vanzandt (May 11, 2022);
Michael Shaffer (October 23, 2022);
Daniel Barnett (February 13, 2024);
Anthony James Raimo (October 8, 2024);
Lance Heverly (November 21, 2024); and
Justin Johnson (July 12, 2025).

Before Justin’s death, Superintendent Close was specifically placed on notice that an incarcerated person could remain concealed behind a covered cell window for an extended period without meaningful intervention. On November 21, 2024, Lance Heverly died by suicide at SCI Houtzdale after remaining inside his RHU cell with his cell window covered for approximately 90 minutes. Despite that prior death and the obvious danger presented when correctional staff cannot visually confirm an incarcerated person’s condition, the same fundamental monitoring failure occurred less than 8 months later when Justin remained concealed behind a covered window for more than 90 minutes.

Following Justin’s death, the same pattern continued. Merritt Dudas died by suicide at SCI Houtzdale on October 20, 2025, and Edward J. Bower, Jr. died by suicide there in February 2026 under similar circumstances. Although these subsequent deaths are not alleged as notice preceding Justin’s death, they further demonstrate that the systemic deficiencies in suicide prevention, observation, monitoring, and intervention alleged herein persisted after Justin’s death.

…Superintendent Close is liable because he knew of and disregarded these systemic deficiencies. The pattern of suicide deaths was sufficiently widespread and persistent that it could not have occurred without the knowledge and acquiescence of Superintendent Close.

In addition, Superintendent Close failed to adequately train and supervise correctional staff in suicide prevention and emergency response, despite the obvious and well documented risk of inmate suicide in custodial settings. Nationally recognized standards, including those promulgated by the National Commission on Correctional Health Care (NCCHC) and the American Correctional Association (ACA), which the PADOC has adopted in its own policies and procedures, require correctional staff be trained to recognize and immediately respond to warning signs of suicide, including verbal threats, behavioral deterioration, and efforts to obstruct observation.

These standards further require immediate intervention when an inmate blocks visibility into a cell, as such conduct is widely recognized as an acute indicator of imminent self-harm risk. They also require timely and documented observation, communication with mental health personnel, and rapid emergency response.

Despite the existence of these well-established standards, Superintendent Close failed to ensure staff at SCI Houtzdale were properly trained, supervised, or disciplined for noncompliance. Alternatively, to the extent any training existed, Superintendent Close failed to enforce it, thereby rendering it ineffective.
The need for training and supervision in this context was obvious.

Suicide is a leading cause of death in correctional institutions, and the warning signs exhibited by Justin—including obstructing visibility into his cell—are universally recognized as requiring immediate intervention. Superintendent Close’s failure to act in the face of this known risk constitutes deliberate indifference.

As a direct and proximate result of these acts and omissions, Superintendent Close knowingly permitted a dangerous environment to persist at SCI Houtzdale in which inmates at risk of suicide were not adequately monitored or protected. This environment directly led to the violation of Justin’s constitutional rights and his death.

Asa Hawks is a writer and editor for Starcasm. You can contact Asa via Twitter, Facebook, or email at starcasmtips(at)yahoo.com

Similar Posts