RETURN TO AMISH Carmela and Jeremiah are back together

Return To Amish Are Jeremiah Raber and Carmela back together?

Less than a month after Return To Amish star Jeremiah Raber proudly declared himself “single as f**k” after telling his wife Carmela “to get the f**k out of the house,” it appears as though he might once again be married as f**k!

The potential Jermela reconciliation speculation began a little less than two weeks ago after Jeremiah documented the beginning of a mystery vacation with a live Periscope video. He hinted in additional videos over the next few days that he was on the west coast, just prior to starting a road trip back to Florida.

The reconciliation rumor gained momentum due to Jeremiah’s coyness over sharing any details about his trip combined with the inability of folks to come up with another reason for Jeremiah to fly across the country and then drive home.

During the road trip, Jeremiah updated fans with more live streams on Periscope from hotels in locations like Utah and Missouri. In one of his recent videos posted on Facebook, he is documenting a storm in Missouri when a female voice that sounds A LOT like Carmela asks: “What is that sound?”

Here’s the video — see if you think it’s Carmela:





If that’s not Carmela, then Jeremiah has found her vocal twin!

Whether he is traveling with Carmela or not, Jeremiah certainly seems extremely upbeat and happy in his videos — which is good.

If it is Carmela, I’m amazed (given the couple’s history of explosive arguments) that the first thing they did after deciding to patch things up was take a road trip in a car together across the country! Remember, according to Carmela, Jeremiah (aka Jer) isn’t the easiest person to road trip with:

I don’t like traveling long distance trips with kids in the car with jer because if I make wrong turns he yells at me and calls me names .. last time he yelled go die you c*nt b!tch.. and when I don’t listen to how he wants me to drive out of nowhere he puts it in neutral.. so scary! I just don’t want to deal with that I don’t want the kids to hear that either.

I should point out that Carmela specifies that she doesn’t like long distance trips with Jeremiah “with kids in the car.” There is no indication that any of Carmela’s children might be on the trip — if in fact it is Carmela.

Jeremiah mentions that they are currently in talks for another season of Return To Amish, but adds that troubled co-star Sabrina Burkholder will not be included. He also states that show OGs Rebecca and Abe Schmucker don’t want to come back. I assume that Kate Stoltz is also out, so I can’t imagine what producers would have left that they could make a show out of that wasn’t just a Jermela spin-off? Well, I guess it could be a Jeremiah and Mama Mary show! :) #Marymiah

I am guessing that either Jeremiah or Carmela will be addressing the reconciliation speculation soon, so stay tuned!

UPDATE – Still no comments from either Jeremiah or Carmela on social media about getting back together. Jeremiah did post another clip from the road trip, though. Here he is with his very Carmela-ish traveling companion viewing the eclipse in Nebraska:

UPDATE – The Jermela reconciliation has been confirmed! The two posted a video together on Youtube doing the Bean Boozled Challenge — whatever that is:



web analytics


Pin It
  • Gwynedd

    These two are toxic together. They need to split up and stay split.

  • Renee L

    Asa, why are you acting so happy about them being back together? I’m tired of people being under the impression that being with someone, no matter how toxic is better than being alone. This can be a potentially dangerous situation. Just because her kids aren’t with her on the car trip, doesn’t mean she should be there. They are purely toxic. Attention should not even be given to them, period.

    • Lori

      I don’t think Asa is happy at all. He was just pointing out they are back together. I think it’s sad because at the very least she WILL hurt OR worse.

      • therealevilqueen

        Really this site is full of kiss butts over reality stars. They are always praising jerks like Jeremiah and anything to do with them it seems like. IMO if she keeps it up with him she could end up worse then she has. Remember some how this convicted abuser was allowed to get his hands on a gun. That alone is a scary thought even if she didn’t go back to him.

        I hope this show is done and over. You could tell Rebecca and Abe were over the show. Sabrina needs to get her crap together. Mary is nothing more than a liar IMO and far from “Amish”. Nothing but an attention seeker. Toss in the mix of Jeremiah and Carmella, who are 2 people that are in need of some major help as well and need to get their crap together…..and as far apart from each other as can be.

  • http://ontarionorthtoday.com/ Paul

    Sell your soul to be on TV.

  • http://www.iam lucky love

    Marymiah😁