REPORT American Horror Story’s Emma Roberts and Evan Peters are engaged

Emma Roberts and Evan Peters are reportedly taking their relationship to the next level. And unlike their characters on American Horror Story, this step (likely) doesn’t involve inviting another lady into their bed: They’re getting married!

According to Extra, Evan popped the question with a pink and gold diamond ring during a holiday break in New York City. They celebrated their new engagement and New Year with a trip to London. The pair is now back in New Orleans to film the final episodes of Coven.

Off-screen, Emma and Evan made news last summer when she was arrested in Canada following a violent domestic dispute. Evan declined to press charges and Emma was released. They reps later released a statement that said it was “an unfortunate incident and misunderstanding.”