Breaking Amish’s Rebecca bikini photo from 2010 surfaces online

PHoto reportedly of Breaking Amish star Rebecca in a bikini from 2010

In the latest bit of evidence suggesting the cast of TLC’s Breaking Amish actually broke away well prior to the airing of the show, a photo allegedly of Rebecca Byler (who was reluctant to wear a swimsuit during her modeling photo shoot in last week’s episode) has surfaced online in which she is confidently wearing a very revealing bikini for a group photo at a pool party in 2010.

Though there has been no confirmation that the girl is Rebecca, the photo was submitted to the Breaking Amish The Expose Facebook page unanonymously by someone who was at the party and claims to know Rebecca and Abe. (She’s actually the hot-bodded gal standing next to Rebecca) She confirmed that the date of June 11, 2010 that appears on the photo is correct, which is backed up by the fact that the photo was originally uploaded to her account at that time.

Commenters began to ask questions about the picture, including where it fell time-wise in relation to reports that Rebecca had a child with Abe prior to filming the show. Here’s what the submitter of the photo wrote:

yes they have a little girl… i do believe this was just a cpl wks or days she was preg in this photo

Just in case you missed it, here is the photo reportedly of Breaking Amish‘s Abe and Rebecca with their daughter, in which it is clear Rebecca has yet to have her teeth removed:

Photo reportedly of Breaking Amish stars Rebecca and Abe Schmucker with their daughter

And speaking of Rebecca’s fake teeth, the person who submitted the bikini photo also addressed that issue, although I’m not exactly sure how to interpret what she wrote:

and her teeth where with her when she was here

She also offered up an observation on Abe:

i will say abe is nervous on the show he is a very quite person i can see him just going along with it but he does walk the line with rebecca she wears the boots

TLC still remains relatively quiet on the matter, stating only that “There is a lot of information floating around about the group featured on Breaking Amish. Much of it is not true, but some of it is — and is addressed in upcoming episodes.”

We’ll keep updating you on all the “Faking Amish” stories as they unfold. If you like seeing the Breaking Amish gals in bikinis, then be sure to check out our post featuring Kate’s bikini photo shoot as well as a photo of her that she reportedly entered into an online modeling competition in 2010! (We’re still waiting for the inevitable Breaking Amish sex tape.) Stay tuned!

UPDATE – Rebecca was apparently married and ran off with Abe! Click the link for all the details!

UPDATE – Check out Breaking Amish‘s Abe Schmucker’s mug shot photo from a 2008 arrest in Kentucky for public intoxication!


Pin It
  • Courtney

    Did anyone else notice that Abe and Rebecca’s family came TOGETHER to see them in NY and that one of the family members was holding a baby!!!

    • kittycat246810

      I have no idea what to think of this show! I don’t know whether that this show is true or not! TLC needs to start talking!

    • Still Loves faking amish!!

      very good catch Courtney!!!!

    • Jadya

      Nobody was holding a baby, but there was somebody holding a toddler….

      • Taya

        yeah the baby would be 2 now

    • Kristen Murphy

      now i got to watch that again

  • bitch

    Eeww. Her man is an ugly Skarsgaard.

  • Amy

    Has anybody seen the new Proactiv commercial? One of the girls resembles her a lot and is even named Rebecca.

    • Julia

      I agree! I thought it was her too!

  • flinda

    regardless that photo could be from 2013 lol no one ever sets the date on their cameras every time the battery dies especially the people who dont turn off the date stamp

    • R

      Guess that would be kinda suspicious too being how it is only 2012!

    • Bev

      It can’t be from 2012 considering she doesn’t have the dentures in that photo.

    • sbr13616

      Actually that phot. is real, my mom is in the picture with her

      • log

        That cant be your mom that girl looks like she’s 17

  • :/

    Well that’s a piss off..

  • Kayla Gaudet

    honestly, i love this show real or fake. Its an interesting show. I dont think it really matters if its real or fake. people still like it, people still love drama. who cares, stop making such a fuss about it. If you like the show watch it, if you dont like it dont watch it !

    • EllieEnlightened

      This is the problem with the world. They can’t distinguish between real a fake.

  • Bev

    That looks NOTHING like her.

    • j

      You guys must be blind, that looks NOTHING like her. And the bikini picture has some resemblance but not that much…

      • Kyle S.

        you need glasses as much as rebecca need new teeth

  • Paige

    Did anyone else notice that she had her fake teeth in the bikini picture when she was “a few weeks pregnant” but still had her old teeth when she was in the picture with the baby? Makes no sense.

    • sbr13616

      She had two sets of teeth. as weird as it sou.ds this is my neighbors pool party she was at. Rebecca was really there.

  • Jules

    That doesn’t look anything like Rebecca. lol

    • Debbie De Anda


  • Carrie

    If Abe & Rebecca have a daughter and Jeremiah has 3 children, who is taking care of all these children and how often do the Faking Amish cast see their very real children?

  • Marika

    are you guys serious? that girl in the top picture is NOT rebecca and the proactive girl is not her either lol Looks NOTHING like her

    • Debbie De Anda

      It does toooooooo look like her… Are you smoking CRACK????? Get some glasses.. The cat is out of the bag, why try to stick up for TLC and the cast?????

    • log

      The bikini picture is obviously her. Its the exact same girl in the picture with abe?

  • Debbie De Anda

    TLC, I won’t watch your fake ass shows. I freakin HATE reality tv because I have found that it is all BULLSHIT. I want to watch a show that is real and there are no scripts; especially REALITY !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Shame on TLC… I won’t watch this crap anymore…

  • Loki

    This show is almost certainly fake, I wanted to watch originally because I was interested in learning more about the Amish, but there’s no point if it’s not real. I feel like TLC is full of crap.

  • Chelsea Mcneal

    In the picture with the baby, Abe and Rebecca look really young, like maybe 16 at most…a lot younger then on the show now.

  • ana isol

    So y is Rebecca wearin a bikini at the beach but wouldn’t at the modeling casting?? Oh I thought it was against ur religion! What a LOSER !!

    • kayla

      LMAO actually she didn’t want to take the bikini off at the modeling agency because she wasn’t “waxed” hahah if you pay attention next time hunny you will notice that :)

  • Taya

    o.m.g. i can not believe this!!! TLC!!!! WTF!!!!!

  • EllieEnlightened

    Abe’s mother appears on camera. This is a red flag for me. I spent a lot of time in Lancaster, PA and they don’t get their picture taken let alone go on camera. I knew right then something was wrong.

  • Allen

    I know a Guy that says that Abe is for real in the way of his name , but Rebecca i herd thats not her real name , i herd that she lived in Southern Manitoba Canada for some time but i would love to find out her real name ?

  • sara

    That is so her in the pic. Her hair is a diff color. And I told my husband that this show was wack when it started. jeremy is nasty and an instigator. Sabrina is fake as hell. Kate needs help. Rebecca and Abe both irritate me. Rebecca is like the female jeremy.

  • tyco

    thats not her she has dentures

  • nickaleena

    I swear Rebecca is on a “Proactive” commercial. Its the one with the Face scrubber. She mentions the “other brand is $350” the girls name is Rebecca too! Paid actress… I think so-

  • Bonita

    Rebecca’s an FUGULY, NO TEETH, LEGGINGS, SPANDEX WEARING BITCH, the reason she hates Kate is simply because she’s way prettier than her, the bottom of Kate’s feet are way prettier than Rebecca’s face. Both Rebecca and Abe are great together, why should they mate with anyone else and ruin that person’s life with their FUGULYNEST. Abe’s sister didn’t want to go with Abe or Rebecca because she has CLASS and didn’t want to wear spandex, or cowboy wear. Not all Amish is Amish TRASH like Rebecca and Abe, thank GOD Kati Ann went with Kate shopping otherwise her mother would’ve locked her outside.