REPORT 17-year-old Abigail Breslin’s dating 25-year-old Jack Barakat

This is not the kind of connection we saw coming: Former child star Abigail Breslin is reportedly dating Jack Barakat, Holly Madison’s ex-boyfriend.

According to Us Weekly, Abigail and the 25-year-old All Time Low guitarist met at one of his concerts in April. (Many readers said the fact Us Weekly misidentified Jack as the vocalist in All Time Low means the story doesn’t have any credibility… We’ll let you draw your own conclusions.)

Based on “insiders,” Jack and Abigail kept their romance on the down-low ever since, but did make a semi-public debut during the premiere of Abigail’s latest movie, Ender’s Game. Jack also shared the top picture on Instagram, adding “Great pic of my friend @abbienormal9 and myself at the Ender’s Game premiere!”

Beyond their desire for privacy, there may be one big reason Abigail and Jack tried to keep their relationship under wraps: 17-year-old Abigail is eight years younger than Jack.