PHOTO AnnaSophia Robb as young Carrie Bradshaw in Sex and the City prequel The Carrie Diaries

Photo of AnnaSophia Robb as young Carrie Bradshaw in The Carrie Diaries

18-year-old actress AnnaSophia Robb has some big Manolo Blahniks to fill as she tackles the role of a young Carrie Bradshaw in the CW’s Sex and the City prequel series The Carrie Diaries. It’s amazing that the network was able to find another energetic and stylish young actress with a two-syllable/three-syllable moniker, but can anyone ever really replace Sarah Jessica Parker in one of the most iconic roles in television history?

Thanks to the CW we now have our first measuring stick in the form of an official photo of AnnaSophia Robb as young Carrie Bradshaw from the set of The Carrie Diaries! In the picture AnnaSophia is gung-ho 1980s with a bright green leopard print jacket, bedazzling silver sequined dress (with obligatory Madonna-inspired tulle poking out from underneath), rainbow belt, and a ferocious pair of red high heels.

The clothes seem perfectly eclectic, fun, and stylish, and AnnaSophia seems to be downright effervescent with her beaming smile and casual demeanor. In other words, once I get past the dated look, I likes!

For comparison, here are side-by-side photos of AnnaSophia Robb as a young Carrie Bradshaw in the ’80s and Sarah Jessica Parker as a young Carrie Bradshaw in the ’80s (taken from a flashback sequence from the much-maligned Sex and the City 2 film.)

Sarah Jessica Parker and AnnaSophia Robb as Carrie Bradshaw side by side 1980s pictures

Emmy®-winning costume designer Eric Daman (Sex and the City, Gossip Girl) said: “It’s a rare invitation to dress a character whose reputation truly precedes her. Having played a hand in designing for the Carrie we know and love, I am honored to be chosen to carry the torch — to illuminate the woman we know by discovering the young lady she was.”

AnnaSophia Robb photo: Eric Liebowitz / CW
Sarah Jessica Parker Photo: AAR / Fame Pictures

  • Blahblahblah

    This is a horrible idea. Part of the appeal of S&TC was the fact that they were mature (aka OLD) confident, successful women surviving and thriving, determining what they want out of life and talking frankly about sex through it all…..not teens or 20 somethings moving to a big city and trying to make it big. How many times does that story need to be told!? Leave things be. It was a good show, it had a good run, it had one unnecessary movie, a second terrible movie……MOVE ON already! I assure you, the fans have! P.S. why does everyone think women dressed like wh0res in the 80s?

  • Thelma

    SJP looks so damn sad trying to be a teenager.

  • Lisa

    Sarah and Anna have absolutely NO similar facial characteristics. They look NOTHING alike. This time around I think they got the casting horribly wrong. REDO!

    • Mandy

      They did us a favor!! They got the casting wrong LAST time but thankfully aren’t subjecting our eyes to another horse face!

  • a

    Annasophia robb looks good in the 80’s look. Sarah jessica parker? Not so much! Let’s not judge the film before we see it..