He says, he says: Did Andy Cohen and Lance Bass sleep together?

On Tuesday, Andy Cohen admitted that the most famous person he’s slept with is Lance Bass — but the former NSYNC singer seems to remember it going a bit different.

Andy made his confession when pressed by Sonja Morgan on an episode of Watch What Happens Live when she asked who’s his most famous conquest.

“The most famous person I ever slept with, I guess, is Lance Bass,” Andy answered.

However, on Thursday’s edition of SirusXM’s Dirty Pop — after plenty of “Andy and Lance had sex” headlines — Lance said that isn’t exactly how things went down.

“First of all, I’m not going to tell you what I do in the bedroom,” Lance said. “Sex is a broad term… Like, ‘Andy banged Lance.’ When did he ever say that? This is an old story. Three years ago we told everyone we hooked up… Now it’s getting into who did who? I can just tell you right now, there was no Andy D going in my B… I’m not going to tell you what went down, but it’s not what people are thinking.”

Lance, who is now married, also confirmed that whatever encounter they had occurred years ago.

“We didn’t know each other that well. It was like, ‘Ah, I wonder if I could date this guy?’ It was that kind of thing,” he said, explaining they are now “too great of friends” to ever go down that road again.

Now we (kind of) know!