VIDEO Should male authority figures be spanking high school girls?
          

Taylor Santos is a straight-A sophomore at Springtown High School near Fort Worth, Texas. Recently she allegedly got caught letting another student cheat off of her work and chose corporal punishment, read “spanking,” over a suspension because she didn’t want to miss any class time.

She went to the Vice Prinicipal’s office where her mother, Anna Jorgensen, was contacted via the telephone. Mom said she was okay with it as long as her daughter was. It turns out that Texas is one of 19 states in which corporal punishment is still legal in the public school systems. Following the administration of her daughter’s punishment Jorgensen was red-faced with anger, but why?

She told local news affiliate WFAA that it was her understanding that it was supposed to be a woman who administered the paddling but instead it was an as yet unidentified male Vice Principal. Well, mom was right as the written school policy states that, “spanking of a student can only be done by a member of the same sex.” The spanking was done behind closed doors with a female officer on hand to observe.

Her daughter’s backside was fire-engine red and looked as if it had been “burned and blistered,” according to Jorgensen. She took pictures for proof of her claims. Here is the local report:

Another student from the same school, Jada Watt, admits to having smarted off to this same Vice Principal and got the same treatment. The only difference in her case was that it was a male officer observing the administration of the paddling. Jada’s mother, Cathi, was not happy when she found out. She said:

“A swat is a swat–yes it is and they do sting. But to bruise a child? If I had done that, they would have called CPS on me. She added, “Two men giving her a swat behind closed doors, that is creepy.”


^Jada and Cathi Watt

There is a recent law in Texas that provide parents the right to disallow schools from the practice by requesting as much. As for this local school board, they’re actually looking to change the same-sex rule because they claim the overwhelming number of male higher-ups make the particular rule extremely difficult to enforce.

Jorgensen intends on attending the upcoming school board meeting to voice her concern over possibly changing the rule.

“I think Taylor is proof that we need to keep that policy. I don’t believe a man intentionally meant to do that to her, but it still happens, because men are too big and strong to be hitting 96-pound girls.”

As a parent I’ll admit there’s no corporal punishment in my home. That’s a personal decision and I don’t frown on those who do. But as a father of a female, I can say unequivocally that I would never condone behind-closed-doors paddling of my daughter by a grown man while another man watches.

What do you think about this idea of requiring someone of the same sex to administer corporal punishment at public schools? Heck, what’s your opinion of the fact that they still paddle kids at school?

Follow Us





spacer

You also might like

spacer
  • No items
    • ambleg

      There is no way in hell i would let someone other than a close family member (me, my sister, my mom, my husband, his sister, or his mom) spank my child. That’s my job if I am present and my family’s job if they are babysitting. The school should not have that “privilege.”

    • dev

      Corporal punishment as a method of detaining a student is a little barbarian, if I can say anything about this. Besides the subject of same or opposite sex, at that age it’s just teaching violence. That’s something you do on a child, not a teenager, of course they’ll choose that option.

    • Nathan

      I saw this story on Yahoo a couple of days ago. What most people commenting on the story seemed to gloss over was the fact that both this girl and her mother consented to the paddling. It is not as if this was done against the mother’s will.

      Also, I don’t see why people are making a big deal out of the fact that a male was the one who did the paddling. If the paddling was done in a room with a witness present, with the girl fully clothed, and with a paddle, I don’t know why some people are trying to make this sexual. Honestly, if you hear “paddling” and the first thing that comes to your mind is sex, maybe you are the one who is a little perverted, not the vice principal.

      • Ashley

        No one said anything about it being sexual…. the last quote from the mother says that men are too big and strong to be hitting 96lb girls…. its the fact that he bruised her

      • Nikki

        Oh, I will have to disagree with you here. Sorry, but these days ANYTHING can be made sexual. Foot fetishes, muscle worship, and spanking with or without clothing are just a few of the sexual things that are becoming somewhat normal these days. Honestly, I wouldn’t be shocked if one day, we find out that something like this is going on in a school, someone has a hidden camera, and is selling or putting it online as jail bait fetish videos. Underage girls and spanking behind closed doors by an adult male? Sorry, there is nothing normal about that. I live in the real world, a world that is VERY scary, a world where there are sexual predators in our neighborhoods, churches, schools, and workplaces. No, I’m not saying this is the case, but I see no reason for any strange man to be making any sort of contact with a teenage girl’s rear end.

    • sausagekingchi

      I’m actually shocked to hear that physical punishment is allowed in any school this day and age, regardless of the sex of any of the people involved. I mean really? I grew up Catholic and went to a Catholic school and even there they stopped with any type of smacking, spanking, paddling, hitting back in the 80′s. I can’t imagine anyone allowing there child to be punished in this manner by anyone other than themselves or a trusted family member. If I was the father of one of these girls and I had heard that a male did this (on top of the creepy abuse policy to begin with) I’d have beaten that man senseless.

    • Nikki

      This whole story is extremely creepy and disturbing to me. No, I am not “anti-spanking”, but first of all, I can’t imagine being okay with another person (especially a grown man) spanking my child. Sorry, but even in the schools, in church, etc. there are a ton of perverts and no…just no. Secondly, I have an issue with the spanking of teenagers. That’s just weird to me. After a certain age, spanking is not even an effective punishment. I don’t even know that was why an option in this case. She should have been suspended for a few days and that’s it. I don’t understand why students would be allowed to choose their punishment, and why students in a high school even have spanking as an option. Not saying that this particular administrator is, but I really get a pedo vibe from the whole thing. It creeps me out and is completely unacceptable IMO.

    • Mia

      If a male adult paddled my daughter I would pull my daughter out of the school and have them in court faster than the school could even call home to apologize for the “misunderstanding” which is what I’m sure they’d try to pass it off as. I wouldn’t stop until every person in charge that knew the rule was being broken lost their job either. That is NOT okay. I don’t agree with paddling in schools unless it is a last resort of punishment, but if a school district really thinks paddling is okay and they’re giving me the option to opt out then that’s their prerogative, but if he had done that 10 feet off the campus he’d be in jail for sexual harassment and have to register as a sex offender. Also important detail, I am VERY Pro-Spanking when it comes to little kids in your home. I was spanked when I was younger and I plan to use it as a form of punishment with my children when they just aren’t responding to verbal directions. But I would never let other people that weren’t my husband or I’s siblings or parents spank the child either. This is ridiculous and they’d be so tired of me by the end of it all that they’d probably ban the rule altogether if it happened to my daughter.

    • Bailey

      Why the buttocks and not the hands/arms if anything?
      Was she bare bottom?
      I didn’t know this was a thing they still did today.
      I live and grew up in Canada, and as a child none of my friends, cousin, myself or my siblings ever got spanked, let alone getting spanked at school.
      Also, aren’t these girls a little bit old to be getting their bottoms beat?? What happens if the student is 18??

      Extremely bizarre.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Xing-Chow/100002179025895 Xing Chow

      This debate is absurd. She asked for a beating and got one. Now the little baby’s gonna cry about it because it hurt too much? This (along with the anti bully movement) is why we’re all going to be speaking Chinese in 40 years. The loss of empire begins with such weakness.

    • Oklahoma Father

      As a father– no way would my daughters be spanked by a male teacher/school official. Back in the 70′s when I was in school, I observed, and intervened when it happened, a male teacher paddling a female student in my grade in the hallway. After the 1st swat the girl reached her arm back and the next swat hit her forearm. I heard the arm break from the force of that blow and slammed the teacher away from her. Subsequently I was expelled for assaulting a teacher yet the teacher wasn’t disciplined at all for breaking the girls arm. 2 days later I was readmitted after my fathers lawyer had a talk with the school board.

 

Advertisement: