Are Casey Abrams and Haley Reinhart of American Idol dating?

Casey Abrams and Haley Reihnardt are reportedly hooking up on American Idol

According to an American Idol insider, contestants Casey Abrams and Haley Reinhart may not just be making beautiful music separately on stage, but also together behind closed doors!

An Idol insider tells In Touch that Haley, 20, and Casey [also 20] have become quite the cozy couple. Though he once serenaded a female friend in the audience, he’s really into Haley. “Most of their downtime is spent together and they have a very touchy-feely relationship,” says the insider. “They’re always lying on each other when they’re around the other contestants and everybody thinks they’re hooking up.”

You know what they say, “American Idol hands are the devil’s tools!”

And just so this post has a little something of value besides a bit of gossip, here’s a photo of Haley Reinhart touring Europe in 2009 with her High School band:

American Idol's Haley Reinhart on a band trip in Italy

So what do you think? Will Season 10 of American Idol produce the next Sonny and Cher with Casey and Haley?

Actually the question is moot anyway because the only AI love affair that matters is our infatuation with the next American Idol winner, PIA TOSCANO!

PIA! PIA! PIA! (Go ahead and unleash a non-ballad Pia so the judges will be quiet and we can end the competition now under the mercy rule!)

Top Photo: Fox
Bottom Photo: