Breaking Amish L.A.’s Betsy freaked out her castmates when she started doing stuff with candles. Unlike the first Breaking Amish, which had unfounded accusations of witchcraft, Betsy openly admits that she’s been practicing witchcraft for years, and that she’s even had sex with Satan.
Betsy says she’s been practicing witchcraft for most of her life, and that he connection with the spirit world is “probably really scary to some people.” She says the demons have been around her a lot since she came to L.A. and instead of using candles to chase them away, she’s been using them to allow access to her.
“I don’t know if you’ve ever heard of having sex with something, literally in your sleep. You wake up, and you’re like ‘Whoa! What just happened?’ You have sex with Satan. It just felt like a friggin’ snake went up my *bleep*.” CLICK HERE to see this clip.
She says she doesn’t talk to a lot of people about it because it freaks them out. She says that everyone should believe in witchcraft because Satan is everywhere.
Betsy opened up to Andrew about her witchcraft, and warned him to keep her candles lit. Then he woke up and said everything was weird and gave him goosebumps. When the rest of the group comes home they decide to blow out the candles so they wouldn’t burn down the house. Iva got so scared she called her boyfriend Sam, and said there was a lot more going on that she couldn’t talk about. Later when everyone reveals that Betsy has tried to flirt with them, Iva reveals that she and Betsy had made out.
When they confront Betsy about her hobby, she tells them they have no room to judge because they’ve never been on “The Dark Side.”
Matt revealed that his mom once got into witchcraft, but renounced it after she went to a church a prayed. Lizzie is concerned about her baby being exposed to whatever Betsy’s doing. Matt tries to convince the group to pray over Betsy to heal her. When they left the house, Betsy trashed the house and put a hex on everyone. She even messed with Matt’s sewing machines and thread, which really upset him because he felt he had done what he could to help her when everyone else turned against her.
Later, Andrew fell and hurt his ankle, which he suspected was the result of a curse.
They kicked Betsy out of the house, mostly because Iva said Betsy took advantage of her by kissing her and putting her hand down her pants while she was sleeping after a party. Iva even filed a police report even though “Amish people usually don’t go to the police.” Betsy’s side of the story is different, though. She says the whole thing was Iva’s fault. Betsy said that she and Iva were grinding on Devon while partying. The next morning, corroborated by video footage, Iva tells Betsy they can’t tell anyone what happened that night, but Betsy told Andrew that something happened with her, Iva and Devon. Andrew told Iva what Betsy said, and Betsy said Iva started making up lies about her.
Iva’s comments on the situation “I want to kill her. I don’t ever want to see her again.”